Misunderstanding
Islam
What two students have to say about the campus climate for Muslims
Introduction:
A year has passed since the terrorist attacks on the World Trade
Center, the Pentagon, and the plane that crashed in Pennsylvania,
and PAW's staff writer Kathryn Federici Greenwood caught up with
two Muslim students, senior Raquiba Huq and sophomore Abdullah Kandil,
to explore their perspective on life in America and on Princeton's
campus since September 11, 2001. Huq, whose parents came to the
U.S. from Bangladesh and now live in Plainsboro, New Jersey, is
president of the Muslim Students Association. She is majoring in
the Woodrow Wilson School with a certificate in Near Eastern Studies.
Kandil, the vice president of the Muslim Students Association, was
born in Boston to Egyptian parents, who have just moved from Washington,
D.C., back to Cairo.
KFG: What were your first reactions when you learned of the attacks
on 9/11?
Abdullah: I couldn't believe it. It didn't hit me until the next
day when it was still in the news. I was really disappointed that
some Arabs were behind this. I told everyone I talked to that the
attackers don't represent us and that they don't represent Islam,
and that they are outcasts. I tried as much as I could to distance
myself from them and their actions.
Raquiba: I was in England for a semester abroad. It was very weird
being in a different country at that time. Luckily we were
in a group of 12 so we had each other. But it was still very weird.
We couldn't even call America for a while. We couldn't give blood
like everyone else. For a while there were signs in at Victoria
Rail Station in London that said, "No flights to America."
It was hard being away.
It was a double blow for us as Muslim Americans because on one
hand we were worrying about our country and our friends back home,
but also whether anyone in this time of intense mourning and grief
would take any actions against our families or mosques.
KFG: Did anything happen to your family?
Raquiba: No.
Abdullah: Our mosque in D.C. was vandalized and there were a couple
hate crimes during that period. And some of my Arab friends at George
Washington University [in Washington, D.C.] were attacked by other
people.
KFG: Have you noticed any change in student interest about Islam
and the Arab world?
Raquiba: I think interest in learning more about the region has
grown. Enrollment has gone up in classes being offered this year
on "State, Society, and the Challenge of Democracy in the Middle
East," "The Roots of Bin Ladenism," and "Introduction
to the Middle East." Even the Arabic department has seen an
increase in students. Usually there are eight to 10 kids in Arabic
101 and this year 40 students showed up the first day.
KFG: How about over conversations at dinner have your friends
been more inquisitive about your religion and culture?
Abdullah: I have five roommates and they're all asking me questions
about Islam and what Islam thinks about this or that.
KFG: Do you ever feel frustrated with Americans' lack of understanding
about the history and culture of the Muslim world?
Abdullah: Well yeah, whenever you have ignorance and people react
based on ignorance, it's always frustrating. But at Princeton I
haven't faced any biased people.
Raquiba: It's kind of hard when you talk to people who have these
opinions about what's going on in the Middle East but who don't
know historical facts such as that America supported Iraq in the
1980-88 war, or that the U.S. gave aid to freedom fighters in Afghanistan
before. It's a bit frustrating because in order to make an educated
opinion of what's going on today you should know about what went
on in the past. I know it's asking a lot for everyone in America
to know all that, but I think definitely now there's more heightened
interest in these issues.
KFG: What are your parents hearing in Cairo regarding sentiment
toward America?
Abdullah: I know there is anti-American sentiment now everywhere
in the world, except America, because of Iraq.
Raquiba: I can't speak for any country in the region because I
don't really know, but I'm sure it's there. I think sometimes that
sentiment is misinterpreted here though. People in the government
and newspapers will say people in Arab countries are jealous of
what we have and resent our freedom and wealth. But I don't think
it's that superficial. It's not that they don't want us to have
natural resources and goods and services but that they feel these
resources are unfairly distributed and manipulated beyond their
control.
KFG: Do you read news produced in Egypt?
Abdullah: I don't, but my parents do. When they were here they
had satellite and they would watch Egyptian channels, Al Jazeera.
I don't, because I was here on campus.
Over there during the war on terrorism in Afghanistan, Al Jazeera
would go into the places that had been bombed and then show the
brutality of some of these bombs. And they interview the families
of the innocent people killed.
KFG: What can a place like Princeton do to help build better relations
with the Arab and Muslim worlds? What will help open up lines of
communications and understanding?
Abdullah: During 9/11 Princeton had a memorial service and they
had a Jewish rabbi and a Christian minister, but they didn't have
an Islamic imam. And I thought if you really want to unite the people
then they should have made an effort to find some representative
of Islam. And [the university should] incorporate us into their
services and have more conferences so people can be educated. Because
people aren't well educated about Islam. They have a lot of biases,
and if Princeton educates the people here, at least the people here
on campus, that's already a start. These people are going to go
on and be politicians and teachers, and if they understand us then
that's the best thing Princeton can do.
KFG: So do you think there's not enough of this educating going
on now?
Abdullah: No. There was an Islamic conference last weekend, which
was really good, but I think everyone that showed up there was a
professor. None of them were students.
Raquiba: Princeton's had a few similar conferences. There are
two coming up this fall in religion and politics. So there have
been conferences, and that's a step. Getting the students to come
I don't know if that's something that Princeton can do. It
has to come from the students.
And it's important to offer classes that it offers now. Maybe
Princeton could offer more on the cultural and religious side as
opposed to just the political issues affecting Muslim people. To
understand more about the people and their way of life, you need
more cultural and religion classes. At present there's "Intro
to Islam" and two higher level ones that not many people take
advantage of, called "Intro to Islamic Law" and "Readings
in the Qur'an."
Also, I think we only have one Muslim faculty member.
KFG: Has anything about the Muslim Students Association changed
since 9/11?
Raquiba: This year we're having a lot more observers come. More
people are interested in being in our discussion groups Muslims
and non-Muslims. We are trying to get more speakers to come.
KFG: Is there anything else students could do to increase understanding
between Muslim community and West?
Abdullah: A good way to introduce Americans to our culture is
to actually have some Arabs on campus. I think there are only like
five or six undergrads in all of Princeton that are Arab. I know
my brother at MIT has at least 10 friends who are Arab. So Princeton
could do a lot on that side.
Raquiba: It might be the case that a lot of Arabs don't apply
because they realize there aren't many here.
Abdullah: No I don't think that's the case.
Raquiba: Princeton should actively work on getting more Arab students
to apply and come to.
KFG: But as it's become tougher for foreigners to get student
visas, that will discourage Arab students from applying.
Abdullah: You don't have to get foreign Arabs, you can get Arab-Americans.