SOCIOLOGY 338: LATINOS IN THE US CUBANS IN MIAMI About 1.7 million Cubans or people of Cuban descent. Who are these guys? Almost 100% of Cuban population is urban and over 52% are in Miami/ Ft. Lauderdale. As usual, lets begin with a statistical tour of the Cuban-American population and the context in which they live. Florida is fairly unremarkable state in term of it socio-economic ranking High service dependence Most remarkable is that it is first in terms of violent crime--- a lot of this in its major cities. As with other states, it is increasingly Hispanic (not necessarily Cuban) 1995 2025 White 12 M 16.5 M Black 2M 3.5M __________________________________________________ Hispanic 1.9M 4.9M What about Dade County? Closer to size of San Antonio-- 2 million in 1995 In the aggregate, Dade County is poorer and less educated than the state as a whole (but this is hiding a great deal of inequality and difference inside the county). A major part of this is geographical. a great deal of racial and ethnic segregation. (Map of the city) 50 % of the population is Hispanic 60% of these are Cubans (30% of total Dade) other major groups are Nicaraguans, Colombians, and Dominicans Hispanic population largely classifies itself as white (87%)-- note difference with LA Spanish language much stronger here as roughly 90% of Hispanics claim they speak it at home. Part of this has to do with large groups of recent immigrants. Fully 45% of the population is foreign born! How about the measures we have used before on education and income? Census numbers available are for Hispanic Pop in Dade County-- I will give you more exact Cuban numbers in a minute. Education Non-H H: 25% of those >25 w/o HS Diploma Hispanics: 45% Non-H H: 24% of those >25 have a college degree Hispanics: 14% Note that these numbers are still better than LA. Income: per capita income for Non-H in 1989: $13,600 per capita income for Hispanics in 1989: $10,800 much less of a gulf than we had seen previously. You also see a little MORE of a middle class (a la San Antonio) 51% of Hispanic families under 25K and 6.7% over 75 K Lets just look at Cubans (not just in Miami) education--- 46% did not have a HS diploma and 16% had a bachelors degree. note the spread-- the below HS numbers do not change very much but the college numbers go up. What is going on? A generation effect. US born Cuban Americans have actually a better educational performance than Anglos! much more bimodal distribution of key characteristics inside the population. important here to remember that Median age in 1980 was 37.7 vs. 30 for US. about half the ratio of people under 18 years old as found in other Hispanic groups. much lower fertility and reproduction rates. actually a population whose demographic presence might begin to decline. In income, Cubans were lagging behind Anglos, but came close to average of Dade County as a whole--- way ahead of other Hispanic groups. If we look at Cuban Americans born in the US, however, C-A’s do better than Anglos again. 55% of US born CA had HH incomes over 30K vs. 44% of Anglos 37% of US born CA had HH incomes over 50K vs. 18.1% of Anglos Very few US born CA under poverty line. Not surprisingly, much higher rates of professional and managerial positions. Also big generational differences when you are dealing with identity--- much more identification with US than with Cuba.---- and much lower levels of use of Spanish. Yet, interestingly, second generation claim higher levels of discrimination than 1st generation. You have a very clear case of extremely successful assimilation into US society following a relatively successful immigrant experience. Certainly if we look at family structures, we see less of the disruption found in other Latino communities. Fewer kids in one parent families Important to remember both sides of the story---- Lets first look at how they got here. Cuban presence in the US actually goes back to 19th century. Dating back to migrations form development of cigar industry in the US in the 1850s and 1860s waves following dislocation caused by first war o independence and then 1898. Centers included New York, Key West, New Orleans, and Tampa Latter is home to a relatively large CA community that has been here for several generations. But the most dramatic growth begins after revolution in 1959 Came over in four big waves: 1959-1961, 1961-65, 1980, and now 1994.. Rough numbers (the best I could come up with) 1961-1965: 500,000 1980: 125,000 1994: 30,000 First two waves fit the traditional image of relatively white from MC and upper class Mariel and 1994 waves have tended to be more from working class and also larger percentage of black or mulatto. Next we will turn to what this population did in terms of political and economic success. Cuban American Politics CA Politics in Miami are important because they represent one possible model for obtaining national prominence. Moreover, they represent a very different model of identity politics. Finally, they have served as a precursor of a lot of issues First bilingual program in 1963 First English-only movement in 1980 a lot of anti-immigrant feeling in 1960s, 1980 and in 1994. great concern is that it represents a prominent example of Latino-Black conflict. We can look at this on three levels: 1) Political preferences of the CA community Parties issues 2) Dynamic of national influence CANF Regional concentration 3) Exile Representation CANF CCD Relationship with Cuba 1) Political preferences of the CA community Parties important to realize that despite reputation o the community, CA are not necessarily more likely to participate in political activities tends to be correlated with same things as in the rest of the pop: education and income same thing with political knowledge. there is the fanatical Cuba issue, but again this is arguably a minority traditionally dominated by Republican party--- up to 70% in vote in 1989-90, close to half said they were Republicans and only <15% Democrats. but in 1996, gave half of support to Clinton The Republican support is partly a reflection of conservative position of the community racism class position but more has to do with exploitation of single issue of Fidel the two congressional representatives are republican but their support has to do with leadership of anti-Castro efforts. issues anti-communism and anti-Castroism in 1985, 3/1 margin against normalizing relations with Cuba 50% supported a US invasion (Miami) this remained in 1989, but a considerable difference with the younger generation being more willing. Manichean view of ideology and politics includes an unwillingness to accept opposition voices in the community Max Castro account of different Miami Herald and Nuevo Herald headlines. Different view of the US seen much more a s a savior involves an element of reciprocity difference on ethnic discrimination with older CA not seeing that much discrimination against "Latinos" this goes along with a refusal to be seen as a minority exiles not migrants but this hasn’t stopped a lot of Cubans form using "minority benefits" root of anger with 1994 decision on rafters. generation gap here increasingly however some link with other groups on opposition to English only, etc. less support for increased government spending for example, much lower levels of support for government spending oriented toward its own community (different from MEX and PR) small level of distrust in government as in population, but older generation seems to rust government more. increasing activity in labor unions as the middle-class enclave effect declines. 2) Dynmaics of influence Openly dominant in local politics increasingly difficult to find prominent Dade Co. politicians who doesn’t have a link to Cuban community part of the reason is turnout in a congressional election 70% Cuban turnout vs. 33% for Black pop. Needs of Cuban community tend to predominate Not only doe sit help if you are Cuban you have to cater to Cuban tastes and sensibilities Very nasty politics with accusations of everything imaginable. Cultural dominance is probably the most extensive of any of the cities we have looked at You have Spanish culture thrown in your face quite a bit in Miami Businesses-- "English spoken here" Bilingual Ed in Coral Gables school in 1963 1973 declaration of bilingual county 1976 creation of El Herald. one reason why is has been the home of some of the worst political backlash against Latinos. 1980 English Only support from non-elite whites some support from Black population Latin-Black relations are probably the worst in Miami black population has practically been disenfranchised racism geographic isolation lack of resources This dominance may be shattered by increasing class divisions inside Dade County and the splitting off of the County into different incorporated cities. Also influential nationally Cuban Americans dispropotionally able to influence US foreign policy especially towards Cuba but also on other issues such as Angola and Savimbi. US policy remains an embargo and a refusal to deal with Fidel regime. establishment of Radio and TV Marti virtual veto power over relevant bureaucratic appointments How? CANF became the dominant player in the 1980s in alliance with Reagan. led by Jorge Mas Canosa wealthy businessman autocratic tendencies widely seen as a potential dictator in post-Castro Cuba political and economic intimidation links to more extreme groups (Alpha, Omega) who have engaged in terrorism. several defeats-- most prominently Fidel is still there. but still dominant. major backer of Helms-Burton how? gave $750,000 to candidates individual members gave even more can target and destroy politicians Regional concentration Miami plays major role in Florida politics Cubans way over-represented in terms of issues since they are only 7% of electorate in Florida-- but they can be "purchased" easily. Pain/pleasure syndrome in US politics 3) Exile Representation declining levels of identification with the community and positive self-image thereof. CANF and Conservative Wing Media AM Radio has played a major role in propagating the right wing views also dominate the two major newspapers at times has exercised veto on Miami Herald. CCD Left of center group composed of business men and some academics (I am member) position is some negotiation with Fidel dismantling of embargo relatively small popular base (even if large part of the pop may agree) Cambio Cubano Eloy Gutierrez Menoyo. Left--- Antonio Maceo Brigade remains fairly marginal. Relationship with Cuba The dismantling of a community? Next we turn to the economic souses of the CA THE CUBAN SUCCESS STORY As we have seen, the Cubans are the most successful major Hispanic group in the country. They have higher individual and family incomes more professionals More importantly: more businesses For example, while Miami only has 5% of the Latino population in the US, half of the 40 largest Hispanic owned business are there-- including 2 of the three largest. with its.30,000 businesses it has by far the highest rate of per capita business ownership in the country Cuban owned firm had $5.5 billion in sales in 1987 Total receipts for Hispanic firms in Miami were $3.8 billion--- $450 million more than in LA and $2.1 billion more than in New York! these numbers and reputation should not make us think that all Miami Cubans are rich and powerful. remember that we talked about a generation effect with elderly not doing so well as the "yuca" generation. for example of 25,000 business in 1982, only 12% had any employees and they all together generated only less than 19,000 jobs. the word business may be an exaggeration of a Mami y Papi cafe stand. Hispanics in Miami (no way to break it down) are still over-represented in manual professions. Nevertheless, the Cuban population ( as we saw in the statistics at the beginning of the course) outperforms other Hispanic groups. How do we explain this? Individual level approach: Human capital: Cubans came over with particular skills. Cuban version of Protestant ethic knowledge of no-return focused efforts A common Cuban answer (and it is relevant in what it says about the Cuban-American culture which will become relevant in a little bit) "Cubans just work harder and are smarter" Demographic/Family Structure interesting that when you look at data on an individual level as opposed to family, you get less of a gulf between Cubans and other groups. Components: low fertility no kids high female labor participation Cuban females employment often served as a supplement as opposed to major income. three generation family come over in family units that allow economies of scale in household take care of grandkids steady source of income from social security Structural Approach Places emphasis on context in which population exists. Stepick and Grenier say that Cubans possessed three critical forms of capital: Economic Money--- some actually were able to get money out and they formed a base. Knowledge: training and education Networks: knew US employers or had contacts with future buyers or suppliers. another important aspect was availability of loans because in some banks loan officers were Cubans who were willing to give loans on the basis of known character. Timing: during 1960s boom. Political race effect: people were more ready to hire them because they "looked" white--- displaced part of the African-America population through this. data uncertain on this process Refugee status: had protection of the law did not have to spend a lot of money or time protecting themselves Cuba professionals had government assistance in re-creating their status here. $$$ support from government 75% of Cuba arrivals before 1974 received some government help. could take IRS losses from property in Cuba offered direct assistance CIA one of the largest employer sin the State of Florida Great Society-- provided state support educational grants school loans Affirmative action Social/Community Solidarity Solidarity through language and national origin automatic support network careful not to romanticize it, but it exists Cuban enclave employment Perhaps the most important aspect of this is the number of Cubans who work for other Cubans or for themselves of Cuban Mariel refugees after 6 years in the US, 45% employed by fellow Cubans and another 28% self-employed. compared to 14.6% and 5.4% for Mexicans. Progression from arrival. these jobs have advantages for employees no new language necessary working with compatriots for the employers: they provide loyal employees with emotional links to owner low levels of unionization cheaper source of labor for example--- garment sweat shops in Miami beginning in the 1960s. some also found in Union City construction business finds similar "short-cuts" if we look at recent immigrants from the 1970s and 1980s we find that a) they spend some years under poverty line-- low wages do mean economic suffering b) BUT they rise out of this relatively quickly outstripping comparative groups who came in at the same time. (interesting gender effect here in that female employment lags behind male) Why? less alienating less disempowering? often not a dead-end job, but with some possibility of advancement Foe employers and suppliers-- provide a base of loyal customers. a survey in mid-1980s or 1980 Mariel refugees found that 75% to 80% lived in Cuban neighborhoods shopped in Cuban stores buying Cuban products consuming Cuban media Ethnic solidarity often used to excuse exploitation and thus ethnic accumulation Willingness to accept low wages because of cultural flexibility Community investment-- less "Cuban middle-class flight" more investment in community? Cubans provide for one another Again, this is nto to deny the very poverty which exists in the Cuban community but solidarity tends to disguise it this makes the pain often worse but it might also work in a functional way. Moral community linked to Manichean vision of refugee experience expectation of brotherhood self-policing Solidarity has a very ugly side in that it helps to maintain the Cuban racism refusal to recognize race as an issue in Cuba refusal to recognize race as part of Cuban-American experience. competition might solidify ethnic solidarity Cultural explanation I want to suggest a mechanism through which all these might work This is related to the self-vision of the Cubans discussed above Not supported by a scientific research but by a set of personal impressions That is that the Cubans might succeed because they cannot imagine another possible fate. Let us consider how each of the elements discussed above might contribute to this Human capital: view as professionals come with a high degree of socialization to success Family: support this vision through familial "legends" Structural: Entry into the US is accompanied by perceptive support Enclave contributes to this image Employers and other authorities are Cuban Conclusion: Pintado family story examples and idea of refugee aristocracy