A letter from a reader: From the Archives, 1946

July 21, 2008:

I very much enjoyed Katherine Greenwood’s article on David Carpenter ’08 (cover story, April 23), as I do all the outstanding articles that appear in PAW. I was, however, somewhat disheartened to note the absence of mention of “Harold in Italy,” surely one of the greatest viola concertos written by that still-not-quite-respectable genius of the romantic movement, H. Berlioz, despite Jacques Barzun’s heroic attempt at rehabilitation. Why doesn’t Mr. Carpenter write a piece for his chosen instrument – an instrument I far prefer to the soprano whine of the violin for its warm, sensuous, and compelling tones. He then could, as Paganini did, perform his own pieces, which would surely hasten his own apotheosis.

Once again, thank you for a most interesting article, and I certainly wish Mr. Carpenter all the luck possible in his difficult chosen path!

Los Angeles, Calif.

Respond to this letter
Send a letter to PAW

Go back to our online Letter Box Table of Contents


Current Issue    Online Archives    Printed Issue Archives
Advertising Info    Reader Services    Search    Contact PAW    Your Class Secretary