Tuesday March 11, 2014
Outdoor Action Guide to
Outdoor Safety Management
by Rick Curtis
This workshop is based on the pioneering work in outdoor safety management by Alan Hale who adminstrated the International Outdoor Safety Review for many years.
- OA Guide to Planning a Safe River Trip - an article about how to run a safe river trip that applies the Dynamics of Accidents Model to paddling situations
- OA Guide to Developing a Safety Management Program - an article developing a safty management program for an outdoor organization
- Outdoor Safety Management Workshop - Adobe Acrobat version (30K)
- Accident Scenarios - help you test out your knowledge of the Dynamics of Accidents
1. The Outdoors as a Risk Activity
- How do you define an accident? Definition - chance or what happens by chance; an event that happens when quite unlooked for; an unforseen and undesigned injury to a person; an unexpected happening; a casualty; a mishap.
- Read "Thanksgiving Death in the High Peaks" - Why did this occur? Separate answers into Environmental Hazards and Human Factor Hazards. Use this to define the Dynamics of Accidents formula.
- What are some outdoor program risk activites? What is the highest risk? (answer - driving to the trailhead)
2. Theory Of Accidents - How Accidents Occur
1) Dynamics of Accidents Formula
These two factors can overlap to a greater or lesser extent. The greater the overlap the higher the Accident Potential. The effect of combining Environmental Hazards and Human Factor Hazards multiplies the Accident Potential rather than simply being additive. The greater the number of hazards, the more quickly the Accident Potential can rise. For example:
|2 Environmental Hazards||+||2 Human Factor Hazards||=||4 times higher Accident Potential|
|3 Environmental Hazards||+||3 Human Factor Hazards||=||9 times higher Accident Potential|
2) Examples of Hazards
Environmental HazardsWhen assessing the potential environmental hazards you need to look at three factors.
- Static - activities in which the environment is realtively unchanging (e.g. hiking)
- Dynamic - activities in which the environment change change very quickly in unpredictable ways (e.g. whitewater paddling, biking)
In remote locations you need to exercise additional precuations. One common method of accomplishing this is to increase the rating of the rapid by one class if you are in a remote setting. For example, a Class III becomes a Class IV. This helps take into account the increase in Accident Potential (see below).
Weather and the possibility of weather changes also have a significant impact on Accident Potential.
- Rocky trail
- Exposed ledges
- Cold temperatures
- Overexposure to sun
- Poison ivy
- Broken stove
- Boots not broken in
- Improper clothing
- Inoperative equipment
- Bad road conditions
- Unfamiliar road
- Difficult road (CLASS I - VI)
- Other erratic drivers
Human Factor Hazards
- No awareness of hazards
- No skills to avoid hazards
- Resistence to instructions
- Irresponsible/careless attitude towards self, others, equipment>
- Need to "prove" self, macho attitude
- Poor physical strength, stamina
- Fear, anxiety
- Lack of knowledge of environmental hazards
- Inadequate skills to extricate group and self from hazards
- Poor safety judgement
- Poor teacher of necessary skills
- Instructions unclear
- Poor supervisor, does not correct problems
- Ineffectual under stress
- Lack of teaching plan
- Poor driving skills
- Rushing to meet schedule
- Overly tired on long drives
- Not driving defensively
- Group not yet formed, lacks cooperative structure
- Interpersonal frictions unresolved
- Poor communication patterns excessive competition
- Scapegoating or lack of concern for slow or different individuals
- Excessive pressure or stress to "perform" - macho
- No practice in working harmoniously under stress
- Lack of leadership within group
- Splintering into sub-groups
Accident Scenarios page and see how you do. Also you can think of an accident or near miss situation that you have been in whether on an outdoor trip or in some other setting. Analyze the situation and list the Environmental Hazards and the Human Factor Hazards that led to the Accident Potential and determine what steps could have been taken to reduce the Accident Potential..
4) Teaching the Formula = Reducing the Accident PotentialIt is essential to teach the Dynamics of Accidents Formula at the very beginning of any trip (or prior to leaving campus) so that all participants are aware of how their behavior is directly related to reducing the possibility of accidents. Participants then can take some responsibility for their own safety. The formula gives you five basic things:
- A technique for evaluating risk potential in the field
- A tool for analyzing how accident potential can be reduced
- A decision making tool
- A rationale for why OA has paticular things we teach, particular rules and policies
- A rationale for why you make particular decisions
5) Environmental BriefingA comprehensive Safety Program allows one to intervene to prevent Human Factor Hazards from overlapping with Environmental Hazards and thereby reducing the Accident Potential. In order to do this it is necessary to rethink from Day 1 of the trip what is an environment? In planning a trip the leaders must examine the environment and the activities of the trip in order to ascertain what the possible environment hazards of that trip are. This information must be communicated to the group in the form of an Environmental Briefing at the beginning of the trip with subsequent briefings when there is a change in environment or activity (e.g if a hiking group changes to canoeing the environment and activity have changed and there are different environmental hazards). The first Environmental Briefing should follow the leadersâ€™presentation of the Dynamics of Accidents formula. On longer trips it may be useful to have the participants do some of the Environmental Briefings once they are familiar with the formula. This can be done with the help of the leaders. The Environmental Briefings set a a tone for safety and help inculcate the idea that the participant is responsible for his/her own behavior.
6) What If?It is important to analyze the possible accident potentials from a what if perspective. Ask yourself what is the worst case scenario. Then ask yourself what you can do to reduce the accident potential.
7) Prepare a sample Environmental BriefingYou will be leading a hiking trip on the Appalachian Trail in the Delaware Water Gap in the first week of May. Write a sample Environmental Briefing for this trip.
3. Record KeepingRecord keeping is an important part of any safety program. Keeping records and reports allows OA to find trends in situations that may lead to changes in training for leaders, equipment, activities, and routes.
1) Accident Reports - These are to be filled out whenever there is an accident on a trip. It documents how the accident occurred, where, when and what treatment was given to the injured person(s). These forms are to be filled out under the following circumstances:
- If there is an injury or illness which requires treatment for more than one day of the trip.
- If an injury or illness causes the person to miss some part of the trip (e.g. group has to wait 1/2 day for person to recover).
- If the person needs to be transported to a medical facility for examination and/or treatment (even if they are discharged).
2) Field Information Reports - These forms are filled out whenever there is a â€śnear missâ€ť accident - a situation in which no one was injured but which could have resulted in injury. It is also used to communicate any other useful information that someone traveling in that area would need.
3) Emergency Report Form - This form is filled out whenever there is an injury which requires outside medical assistance. The form is designed to be quickly filled out and to make sure that all necessary information is transmitted to authorities.
4. Pre-trip PlanningThe essence of any safety program lies with pre-planning. It is essential to cover a wide variety of areas before the trip, during, and after in order to maintain maximum safety.
1) Pre-trip Planning
A) Route Planning
- Trail conditions
- Water availability and quality
- Emergency phone numbers
- Weather forecasts
- Daily evacuation plan
- File overall trip plan with program director
B) Application forms from all group members - informs leaders of previous experience, any medical problems, diabilities, allergies, food issues etc.
C) Teaching Plan - a teaching plan should be developed for each major activity that will occur on the trip. This plan should present a well thought-out and step-by-step plan for safely teaching skills. This should also be shown to the program director prior to the trip.
D) Equipment -
- What to bring - Leaders should examine what the equipment needs of the trip are based on activities, location, and weather (see OA Personal and Group Equipment Lists).
- Check it out - Leaders then need to make sure that all participants have the necessary equipment. If people are bringing their own equipment, it must be examined to make sure that it is in good shape. Also all OA equipment should be checked to make sure it is in good working condition.
- How to use it - Participants must be instructed on the safe and appropriate use of all equipment.
2) During the Trip
- Teach the Dynamics of Accidents Formula
- Give Environmental Briefing
- Teaching Skills - (see OA Handout - Teaching a Skill)
- Accident Response - In case of an accident react calmly and thoughtfully so as not to further injure or exacerbate the situation. Specific details of accident response are covered in CPR and first aid training
- Multiplication of Errors - through poor judgement/ overreaction - present an example.
3) Post-trip Activities
A) Record and write up any accidents, near-misses or imformation to be transmitted. Report this information directly to the program director.
5. Implementing Program Change
- Improving the safety of a program involves a combination of all the items discussed above. The basic model for change is as follows:
PRE-PLANNING -----> TRIP EVENTS ----> ACCIDENT RESPONSE ----> REPORTING ----> ACCIDENT ANALYSIS ----> PROGRAM CHANGES ----> PRE-PLANNING
6. Safety = Judgment
- Know your limits and groups limits. Be conservative.
- Be flexible - (e.g. change route if needed) camp early if group tired
Outdoor Action trips and activities are only open to Princeton University students, faculty, and staff. Specially listed activities are open to Princeton University alumni and their families.
All online information at the Outdoor Action Web Site is protected by copyright laws. You may set up links to material found at the Outdoor Action Web Site. Printed versions of the material may be distributed for nonprofit educational use as long as no fees are charged for the material, attributions are made to the author, and no content changes are made. Commercial use of this material either in electronic or printed form is prohibited without express written permission from the author. Copyright © 1995 - 2004, all rights reserved, Rick Curtis, Outdoor Action Program, Princeton University. Send your comments and suggestions on the OA Web Site to Outdoor Action